Tuesday seminar: Trenz, Fiket and Olsen
Hans-Jörg Trenz, Irena Fiket and Espen D. H. Olsen will present the paper 'Deliberation under Conditions of Language Pluralism: Insights from the EuroPolis Deliberative Polling Experiment'.
(Photos: UniOslo and UniSiena)
Abstract
In this paper, we confront some commonly held assumptions and objections with regard to the feasibility of deliberation in a transnational and pluri-lingual setting. To illustrate our argument, we rely on a solid set of both quantitative and qualitative data from EuroPolis, a transnational deliberative experiment that took place one week ahead of the 2009 European Parliamentary elections. The European deliberative poll is an ideal case for testing the viability of deliberative democracy across political cultures because it introduces variation in terms of constituency and group plurality under the controlled conditions of quasi-experimental scientific setting.
On the basis of our measurement of both participants’ self-perceptions and changes of opinions through questionnaires and of group dynamics and interactions through qualitative coding of group discussions we can identify the following patterns: 1) The EU polity is generally recognised and taken as a reference point by participants for exercising communicative power and impact on decision-making, 2) the EuroPolis experiment proves that participants are in fact able to interact and debate across languages and cultures, developing a self-awareness of citizens of a shared polity and thereby turning a heterogeneous group of randomly selected group into a constituency of democracy.
(This paper is a work in progress and thus has limited distribution, please contact us if you want access. Please do not cite without permission from the author.)
Sign up here for notifications of ARENA Tuesday Seminars.